15 November 2026

Parashat Toldot: Seeing Double

L’lilui nishmat Chula Brandel bat Reuven Yossef a’h

I would be the first to admit that one of my passions is reading.  It has been for as long as I was able to comprehend words.  In many ways, it is also a vice.  Ask my wife if I have too many books and her expression of sheer frustration needs no explanation.  Think of a kid in a sweetshop and substitute the wrappers for dust jackets and that pretty much describes yours truly.

Books would be lovely if they did not need somewhere to be stored and displayed.  There are those amongst you who could legitimately solve my problem instantly by suggesting that I purchase a Kindle or another e-reader.  This is a valid argument which falls at the first hurdle since my reading takes place primarily over Shabbat and however much I can try to debate the issue, Kindles are not in any way Shabbat-friendly!  Books are therefore the only option for me to indulge my bibliographic passions.

My taste in literature is eclectic to say the least but pretty much follows a non-fiction route.  Apart from the occasional novel, I can be found reading anything from biographies to religious texts, often taking in books on philosophy and ethics when I’m in the right mood for weightier matters.

A couple of years ago, I happened to stumble upon a book called ‘Stars of David: Prominent Jews Talk About Being Jewish’ by Abigail Pogrebin (Broadway Books, 2005).  The tome does ‘what it says on the tin’ and contains interviews with more than sixty famous landsmen such as Dustin Hoffman, Steven Spielberg, Mark Spitz, William Shatner, Joan Rivers, Gloria Steinem and Alan Dershowitz talking about what being Jewish means to them.

I was intrigued (which is never a good thing because it ends up costing me more money and taking up yet more room on my creaking bookshelves, where space is rapidly diminishing) and decided to research other titles authored by Ms Pogrebin.  Which is what led me to her next project, namely ‘One and the Same: My Life as an Identical Twin and What I’ve Learned About Everyone’s Struggle to Be Singular’ (Doubleday, 2009) which might be one of the most fascinating and, at times, heartbreaking tomes I have ever read.

It is available on Amazon at https://tinyurl.com/yprudw5v

Abigail has an identical twin sister, Robin, a culture reporter at the New York Times who covers ‘cultural institutions, the art world and architecture’ https://www.nytimes.com/by/robin-pogrebin?eafs_enabled=false and because you’ll probably ask, she is a minute older than Robin, but only because she ‘came out one minute ahead’, as their mother had a C-section. Abigail continues: ‘Robin would have exited first in a normal birth and she constantly reminds me of that fact.’

Abigail provides a brief history of growing up with her twin and describes their similarities and differences.  Robin is ‘half an inch taller, wears her hair shorter and prefers more sedate colours.’

In this photo, Abigail is on the right (I think!)


© https://www.newlyweds-blog.com/book-review-and-giveaway-one-and-the-same/

In her book, Abigail journeys around America and abroad to explore the relationships between twins, both identical and non-identical along with their parents, siblings and spouses.  She intertwines this with a narrative about her relationship with her own sister and why they are not as close as they used to be.  She ponders whether one can find singularity in twinship.

To give away more would deprive you of, as I wrote, a fascinating read.

I have long had an affinity with this week’s Parasha of Toldot.  Firstly, it’s my Barmitzvah sidra, so in a way, I feel that I ‘own it’ (in a non-territorial manner), and secondly, as an only child, I’m interested in the idea of two individuals who often share so much in common.

Yaakov and Eisav (notice that I referred to the younger one first) are the first twins explicitly mentioned in the Torah (although according to the Midrash in Bereshit Rabbah 22.2, this honour falls on Cain and Abel who were each born with a twin sister) and if they were meant to be the ‘poster boys’ for the positive elements of twinship, they failed pretty miserably.

From the start, we are told that the boys were struggling with each other in utero.  When Eisav emerged, his brother, Yaakov, clung onto his heel and was named Yaakov precisely because he had clenched Eisav’s heel (which is translated as ‘Akev’) to hold his brother back as though attempting to prevent his brother from emerging first.  Eisav’s name is also derivative of his hairy appearance (se’ar in Hebrew).

We learn later how Yaakov was told by his mother, Rivka, to disguise his smooth hands by covering them in hairy animal skins to deceive his father Yitzchak into giving him the brachot intended for Eisav.

As young men, the Torah describes Eisav as a skilled hunter, a man of the field, whilst his brother was following a more academic path, studying in the tents of his ancestors Shem and Ever (respectively the son and great-great-grandson of Noah - see Rashi on 25.27).

By the end of the Parasha, the relationship between the twins has sunk to such a level that the older one wants to commit fratricide against his younger brother, leading Yaakov to flee for his life to his uncle Lavan in Haran, which we will follow next week.  Fortunately, we read about their reunion following two decades of estrangement but at the end of this episode, they each went their own separate ways, both in a physical and metaphorical sense.

Abigail’s book dissects the myriad relationships that exist between twins but to be honest, none of them result in such an outcome!  That said, we, the descendants of Yaakov, have had a long-standing, bloody and bitter relationship with those of Eisav, the Patriarch of Edom, a nation that begat Rome and further down the centuries, the Christian world.

Abigail’s desire to achieve rapprochement with Robin is perhaps indicative of our wish to bridge the chasm that developed between the descendants of Yaakov and those of Eisav.

Nearly four millennia after the struggle between Yaakov and Eisav, we have witnessed the emergence of a Judeo-Christian alliance that would have seemed impossible just a few decades ago.  One which is described in Wikipedia as ‘the shared historical, religious, and cultural framework linking Judaism and Christianity.’ (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judeo-Christian)

Perhaps one day, the fraternal kinship that exists between Yaakov and Eisav can be replicated to bring a rapprochement between the descendants of two different (non-twin) brothers, Yitzchak and Yishmael.

As followers of the Abrahamic faiths, we have much more in common than that which divides us.  If we can unite to achieve this, we will establish a bond that is as strong as the one which exists between twins.  Imagine how wonderful that would be!

Shavuah Tov.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Parashat Toldot: Seeing Double

L’lilui nishmat Chula Brandel bat Reuven Yossef a’h I would be the first to admit that one of my passions is reading.   It has been for as...